10 Comments
User's avatar
James Stent's avatar

Excellent review. I liked the question you posed in the first paragraph. I believe that the answer is that, given the background, makeup and experience of Xi, an alternative trajectory for China under his leadership would have been extremely unlikely. But the question remains, if another leader had been chosen, could the Party have distanced itself from Marxism-Leninism and set China on a different trajectory? We will never know, but I think that it might have, although the chances of that were limited by the events of 1989.

Rudd's analysis of Xi as a Marxist Leninist Nationalist is important. It should be complemented by further exploration of how much of Xi's thinking and decisions are firmly in the tradition of traditional Chinese autocratic political leadership.

Expand full comment
Jaishankar Gopalakrishnan's avatar

Your review beautifully summarised the author’s observations and analysis. Thank you

Expand full comment
Normie Therapist's avatar

I'm loving this book

Expand full comment
ViolentBee's avatar

Excellent review

Expand full comment
Rajesh Achanta's avatar

Loved your review - I listened to Rudd being interviewed (probably by Hoover Institute folks) about the book about 6 weeks ago - that video is also great. Also appreciate these book reviews.

Expand full comment
Manoj Kewalramani's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Steven's avatar

Great review! 👍

Expand full comment
Manoj Kewalramani's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 5
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Greg Pringle's avatar

Wow! American Spring is a conspiracy theory among conspiracy theories! The current world is a tripod: Xi, Putin, and some anonymous hegemonic “Puppet Masters” who have dominated the West from time immemorial and are using every deceitful trick in the book to convince the people of the West that they are free and living in the best of all possible worlds, all in order to maintain the Puppet Master’s power and dominance.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 21
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Greg Pringle's avatar

QED

Expand full comment